Landmark Committee

Winning team picked to transform downtown University of Toronto campus

sgupta — Wed, 09 Dec 2015 09:58:25 +0000

Winning team picked to transform downtown University of Toronto campus sgupta Wed, 12/09/2015 - 04:58

Cutline

Artist's rendering shows seating for students, tourists on a car-free front campus

Arthur Kaptainis

Author legacy

Arthur Kaptainis

Topic

City & Culture

How would you like to see ��TV's downtown campus transformed?

sgupta — Tue, 29 Sep 2015 11:51:34 +0000

How would you like to see ��TV's downtown campus transformed? sgupta Tue, 09/29/2015 - 07:51

Cutline

��TV wants to know which of four design proposals you think would create the most pedestrian-friendly and welcoming environment (photo by Johnny Guatto)

Arthur Kaptainis

Author legacy

Arthur Kaptainis

Topic

Our Community

More News

St. George campus

Landscape of Landmark Quality Innovative Design Competition

Subheadline

All are invited to view presentations, submit feedback to online survey

Which proposal best addresses the principle of improved pedestrian experience? Which best addresses the principle of enhanced green space?

You can have your say on these and other central questions raised by the Landscape of Landmark Quality Innovative Design Competition.

Four teams have submitted their ideas on how to revive and restore the historic core of the St. George campus. You can view the images online or in a poster display on the main floor of the J. Robert S. Prichard Alumni House at 21 King's College Circle.

View the four design teams' proposals here

The exhibition opened on Sept. 29 and continues through Oct. 2. Opening hours are from 8:45 a.m. to 6:30 p.m. Computer terminals will be available so viewers can provide immediate comment on the project.

“We want your help, your advice, in selecting the proposal that will change the physical landscape of the University,” Scott Mabury, ��TV vice-president of operations and co-chair of the Landmark Committee, said after a public presentation by all four competing teams Monday night in Convocation Hall. “Please give us your feedback.”

The Landmark website includes descriptions, goals, an historic overview and documentation related to the project, including the Open Space Master Plan of 1999 and St. George Campus Master Plan of 2011.

There is also information about the four teams: KPMB Architects + Michael Van Valkenburgh Associates + Urban Strategies; DTAH + Michael Van Valkenburgh Associates; Public Work; and Janet Rosenberg & Studio + architectsAlliance + ERA Architects. Each has a list of subcontractors and collaborators.

The online survey combines multiple choice questions with space for individual comment.

Take the Online Survey here

After public input has been collected and considered, an evaluation committee including representatives of the Landmark Committee and university operations will choose a winner. This team will consult with the university to prepare a comprehensive design. An announcement is expected in November. (Read more about the competition here.)

Before and after images submitted by the four design teams include:

BEFORE: Sir Daniel Wilson Quad at University College (DTAH)

After: Sir Daniel Wilson Quad at University College (DTAH)

BEFORE: King's College Circle looking north (Public Work)

AFTER: King's College Circle looking north (Public Work)

BEFORE: King's College Circle, west side (KPMB)

AFTER; King's College Circle west side (KPMB)

BEFORE: King's College Circle looking northeast (Janet Rosenberg & Studio)

AFTER: King's College Circle looking northeast (Janet Rosenberg & Studio)

picpath

sites/default/files/2015-09-29-leadImage-.jpg

Plans for St. George campus get public viewing

sgupta — Mon, 28 Sep 2015 20:50:46 +0000

Plans for St. George campus get public viewing sgupta Mon, 09/28/2015 - 16:50

Cutline

Four design teams unveiled proposals for transforming ��TV's downtown campus. The rendering above is by MVVA/KPMB media

Arthur Kaptainis

Author legacy

Arthur Kaptainis

Top Stories

St. George campus

Landscape of Landmark Quality

Landmark Committee

Subheadline

Pedestrian-friendly ideas proliferate as four teams weigh in

A pastoral pond in front of Hart House. An elevated walkway to Queen’s Park Crescent. Public art around King’s College Circle. A skating rink outside the J. Robert S. Prichard Alumni House.

These are only a few of the improvements envisioned by the four design teams shortlisted in the Landscape of Landmark Quality process aimed at renewing and restoring the historic core of the St. George campus.

The general public as well as ��TV students, faculty, staff, alumni and stakeholders were invited to a presentation of the plans Monday at Convocation Hall. The event started at 6 p.m. and ran to 9 p.m.

The exhibition now moves to the J. Robert S. Prichard Alumni House at 21 King's College Circle, where entries will be on display just inside the entrance. Computer terminals will be available so viewers can provide feedback on the project.

The exhibition opens at 10:30 a.m. Sept. 29 and will be open from 8:45 a.m. to 6:30 p.m. Sept. 30 through Oct. 2.

“I am immensely impressed by the flair and creativity shown by these finalists,” said Scott Mabury, ��TV vice-president of operations and co-chair of the Landmark Committee overseeing the competition. “The intrinsic beauty and historic character of the St. George campus have obviously fired their imagination.

“What I find equally exciting is the collaborative process ahead. We have put the call out for feedback. Given the quality of these submissions – and the strong feelings ��TV people share about the university they love – I have no doubt that there will be plenty.”

(Rendering by JRS Media)

Ideas range from the necessary and pragmatic to the aesthetic and inspirational. In many cases there is a combination of these qualities.

All the plans propose underground parking in keeping with the common object of eliminating surface parking around King’s College Circle. One proposal, by Public Work + Greenberg Consultants, sees an elevated lip (called The Arc) at the southeast quadrant of King’s College Circle with flowering cherry trees on the crest and athletic faciliites (as well as sheltered bicycle and car parking) underneath. DTAH + Michael Van Valkenburgh Associates propose an “arrival grove” that will connect underground parking to the surface with both steps and a sloping accessible path rather than elevators.

Public Work and Janet Rosenberg & Studio + ArchitectsAlliance propose making a geometrically perfect circle of King’s College Circle (which at present is more amoeba-like than many suppose). DTAH and KPMB Architects also round off the corners in the interests of introducing amenities to the perimeter of this central green space. KPMB suggests an "urban necklace" of pathways around the perimeter.

(Rendering by DTAH Media)

“The clarity and elegance of William George Storm’s 1857 front campus has been compromised over the years by hundreds of small, well-intentioned accommodations,” notes the DTAH brief. “We propose re-establishing the clarity of the circle as a clearing in a more richly planted and expanded landscape frame.”

Three plans imagine a plaza in front of Convocation Hall. KPMB proposes multi-coloured granite surface ("expensive to install, but incredibly enduring") in place of asphalt (the dotted blue surface installed in front of Convocation plaza in August is temporary).

An emphasis on the pedestrian experience is common to all the proposals. Among the locations considered for cafés is a terrace outside the Gerstein Science Information Centre. DTAH sees the Observatory as a tea room and proposes a new study pavilion and terrace outside Hart House.

Rosenberg, DTAH and Public Work suggest installing a pool or pond in Hart House Circle, either to the east or west of the Observatory. These plans recall McCaul's Pond, a body of water predating Hart House.

There is no water in the KPMB plan, but there are columns of oaks along Tower Drive and its extension south of Soldiers’ Tower, as well as a dramatic pedestrian bridge in front of Hart House leading to Queen’s Park Crescent. Public Work also envisions an elevated walkway in this space.

(Rendering by Public Work Media)

DTAH suggests a new pavilion in the vacant space to the south of Prichard House and multi-use plaza in front of this stone building that could accommodate ice skating. Rosenberg proposes a “halo” around King’s College Circle that serves as a jogging track or ice-skating path according to season. All the plans restore the Sir Daniel Wilson Quad and all foresee more rather than fewer trees on the St. George campus.

Aesthetics have been integrated with the need for pedestrian, bicycle and limited vehicular traffic. All the plans address accessibility. “Gradations in tone and texture provide cues to bikers and pedestrians to interact safely without redundant circulation systems,” comments the brief from KPMB on the subject of the granite surface.

While some plans include glass pavilions and other modern structures, they all share a sense of tradition. "How can we make ��TV more like ��TV?" is how Janet Rosenberg expressed her sense of the mission. One of the most radical proposals, The Arc, is surmounted with the University of Toronto motto, Velut Arbor Aevo.

“Toronto is a winter city” remarked one questioner in a Q & A session following the presentations. Responses ranged from the positive effects of improve drainage and the potential views from "extroverted" pavilions to the simple observation that Torontonians could do a better job of celebrating winter.

Another questioner expressed concern over the cost and disruption of installing conventional parking under King’s College Circle. “We have to decide whether it is worth the disruption to achieve a pedestrianized campus,” University College Principal Donald Ainslie, co-chair of the Landmark Committee with Mabury, concluded after various team members made comments. Other questioners focused on the effect of an elevated walkway on views from the ground, the propriety of installing athletic facilities at the centre of the campus and the need for strong basic landscaping support.

A forum for feedback is available at landmark.utoronto.ca. After public input has been collected and considered, an evaluation committee including representatives of the Landmark Committee and university operations will choose a winner. This team will consult with the university to prepare a comprehensive design. An announcement is expected in November.

About 400 attended the Monday event. The plans will be posted at Convocation Hall on Monday night and for the remainder of the week at the J. Robert S. Prichard Alumni House at 21 King's College Circle. For more information go to landmark.utoronto.ca.

picpath

sites/default/files/2015-09-25-front-campus-designs-MVVA_KPMB_media_0.jpg

Competition looks into St. George campus renewal

sgupta — Mon, 21 Sep 2015 15:02:00 +0000

Competition looks into St. George campus renewal sgupta Mon, 09/21/2015 - 11:02

Cutline

(photo by Arthur Kwiatkowski)

Arthur Kaptainis

Author legacy

Arthur Kaptainis

Landmark Committee

Winning team picked to transform downtown University of Toronto campus

How would you like to see ����TV's downtown campus transformed?

View the four design teams' proposals here

Take the Online Survey here

BEFORE: Sir Daniel Wilson Quad at University College (DTAH)

After: Sir Daniel Wilson Quad at University College (DTAH)

BEFORE: King's College Circle looking north (Public Work)

AFTER: King's College Circle looking north (Public Work)

BEFORE: King's College Circle, west side (KPMB)

AFTER; King's College Circle west side (KPMB)

BEFORE: King's College Circle looking northeast (Janet Rosenberg & Studio)

AFTER: King's College Circle looking northeast (Janet Rosenberg & Studio)

Plans for St. George campus get public viewing

Competition looks into St. George campus renewal

How would you like to see ��TV's downtown campus transformed?